Kevin Smith X Batman
Before you start commenting about how I don’t know shit about comic books, know that you’re right; I indeed don’t know shit about shit when it comes to comic books. I’m a casual fan at best. Only months ago did I start reading comics weekly again. I’ve dabbled in the past but I have no opinions on which artists are the best for which characters, which authors ruined the sanctity of characters, and who to worship (aside from Grant Morrison). I have though been looking into the Kevin Smith debate.
The community seems evenly split between the fans and the haters. I would like to take this post to address the haters. From what I was reading this morning on forums/blogs while I was looking for scans, the main hate seems to be that he “ruins” Batman by injecting his own type of humor/storytelling into it. This almost always leads to the supposedly rethorical question “how does he keep getting to write when he does such a piss poor job!?”. It’s actually not a rethorical question; he gets to keep writing because people like what he does and he pulls the numbers the publishers want to see. Whether or not you’re completely outraged at what he writes isn’t important anymore because other people enjoy it (present company included). So what if it’s not the dark gloomy Bats we know and love? Comedy hasn’t killed anyone yet (well….joker disagrees). Smith said it himself that this was out of continuity so why make a big deal out of it. Adam Carrolla always says you should ask yourself “Will this make me happy or make me money?” before you do something. Does whining about trivial shit like this make you money? If so then go ahead, by all means, you’d be a fool not to do it. Does it make you happy? Lord I hope not…saying this as a nerd who just wrote a big blog post on Batman, please go outside.
The thing is, the beauty of comic books is if you don’t like it, you don’t have to read it. I mean sure I know there are some fans who will read every single thing that comes out with the word “Batman” in it but if you don’t like this side story our precious Mr Smith is writing, just ignore it. It will go away I promise. Like a friend told me a few weeks ago
“The beauty of recycling is…I don’t have to do it if I don’t like it”.
Replace recycling with any activity you don’t like and you’re golden.
Now onto what I really wanted to talk about: What makes a Kevin Smith book? Again I’m new to this but as someone who enjoys his works on the big screen, it’s easy to spot his influences on paper and now I just want to have fun pointing out a few of them I noticed as I read his Widening Gyre series last night.
Aquaman “comes to Bruce’s” rescue as the oceanic wildlife warned him someone was in trouble. As it turns out all the dolphins heard was a woman screaming from the shore of a desert island. I should specify screams of a very hot woman, on the beach of a desert island, with Bruce Wayne. As you obviously figured out by now, the only danger she was in was sexual exhaustion.
During the books, Bruce gets closer and closer to this woman (I don’t want to go too much into spoilers), and at the same time, gets further away from Selina Kyle. You see her come back a few times trying to sink her claws back into her favourite playboy billionaire.
After a little Smith-esque back ‘n forth, Batman bails. An issue or two later, she tries again
You’re still wondering why this is still Smith-esque? The next page gives a pretty big hint:
Could you imagine Selina Kyle saying that with any author? In the last issue Batman and his new friend Baphomet interupt a fight between Deadshot and the Cat in question only to find out she orchestrated the whole thing for Bats to pay attention to her. She starts crying and shouts that she even wore all her old costumes for him. Let’s recap shall we.
- A discussion on whether Selina is a cougar (Happened in the few panels before the first scan)
- She does cosplay for him
- She’s not wearing any panties
That’s exactly the kind of humor I’ve come to expect from the writer/director. Hell you almost expect a scene with Bruce and Dick hanging out in the Batcave talking about anal or something. The next page after the teary eyed “I wore a mask for you, she never did that” Catwoman is one page that, despite not being a signature Smith moment, I still wanted to put in here because I laughed my ass off at this point.
I just love the look on Lawton’s face that just says “Yeah…I set myself up for that one”.
One of the most flagrant examples of another kind of humor that Batman is used to: His new girl’s nickname for him. If you re-read the first scan I posted, you’ll see Bruce explaining that she calls him Deedee. For 6 issues you’re left wondering
“Why in the world would the world’s biggest badass let a chick, no matter how hot she is, call him by such a girl name?”
Well, what if it wasn’t so girly? This page in issue #6 explains it all
If that doesn’t scream “Clerks” I don’t know what would. Unless of course her nickname for him was “37″ but that might be a bit too much, both in terms of obvious reference and also in terms of physical impossibility since it’s one night. Seriously…37 in one night…I don’t buy it.
Here is actually the one that seems to have the world riled up
After his first time with the batsuit against an explosion he squirts a few drops in his pants. Now apparently the fans think it’s ridiculous to bring down Batman to such a low level, but isn’t that why Batman is so damn special? Because he’s human?
Here’s what I think is the biggest example of Smith putting himself into his work
Playing with the idea of an @TheGoddamnBatman has to be the best thing ever. If you know Smith, he’s a Twitter king. It’s probably where he has the biggest following (see: Southwest incident) and will sit down at his computer and just tweet people for hours. Now that’s dedication. And now that dedication is put in comically in Batman. Man…@TheGoddamnBatman…I wish.
I want to put in one last scan which isn’t from Widening Gyre but from his previous work on the book Cacophony. I don’t think I need to explain this one at all


